The Pickle Barrel Reviews
The Pickle Barrel has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 53 reviews. Customer feedback on The Pickle Barrel is mixed: The Pickle Barrel reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide variety of products, quality customer service, competitive pricing, and user-friendly website, which strongly appeal to home cooks, food enthusiasts, and gift shoppers. However, The Pickle Barrel is often criticized for its limited shipping options, occasional stock issues, higher prices on some items, and slow delivery times.
53 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
6
2 Stars
3
1 Star
0
How would you rate The Pickle Barrel?
All The Pickle Barrel Reviews (53)
william1972
May 24, 2026
"Prices seemed fair to me!"
The portions were good and the prices felt fair... can’t really complain. I’d go back again!
0
Reply
DebraMcgaha_23
May 23, 2026
"The menu does feel a bit limited"
I mean, don’t get me wrong, the place isn’t bad or anything, but the menu felt kind of limited to me. Maybe it works for some people, but if you’re with a group or someone’s picky, there just isn’t a ton of choice for everyone.
0
Reply
KENNEDY
May 16, 2026
"I had a small problem with my order..."
I had a small problem with my order and expected the whole thing to turn into a ridiculous hassle. But they got back to me quickly and had it sorted without making it complicated at all. It was way easier than I thought it would be, and I really appreciated that. I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
William_vallery01
May 13, 2026
"Booking process needs some accountability"
My reservation experience was just okay. The booking process felt a bit slow, and I wish there had been clearer updates or someone taking responsibility for keeping things moving. It wasn’t a major issue, but it definitely could’ve been handled better.
0
Reply
DianePackard_05
May 11, 2026
"Pretty good, maybe just a bit late"
I ordered dinner from picklebarrel.ca i thought it was solid. The food was packed well, nothing spilled, and it was still warm when it arrived, which I always appreciate.
The delivery did show up about 10 minutes later than the original estimate, unless I’m remembering the timing wrong, so it wasn’t totally perfect. Still, it wasn’t a big deal and overall I had a good experience. I’d probably order again.
The delivery did show up about 10 minutes later than the original estimate, unless I’m remembering the timing wrong, so it wasn’t totally perfect. Still, it wasn’t a big deal and overall I had a good experience. I’d probably order again.
0
Reply
hello_heather516
April 07, 2026
"Payment went through, but the bill was a little confusing"
I paid online and it went through just fine, so that part was easy enough. The receipt did take a bit to show up, though, the charges weren’t super clear at first glance.
0
Reply
AshleyCohen_43
March 22, 2026
"Plenty of solid options for everyone"
I was happy with how easy it was to find vegetarian and gluten-friendly choices here. The server really knew the menu and helped make dinner simple, which I think is a big plus when you have different dietary needs at the table.
0
Reply
Randall.begum
March 19, 2026
"Food was just okay after a long wait"
The food tasted fine overall, but it was kind of hit or miss. Some bites were decent, others were underwhelming. What made it more annoying was having to wait in queue for so long before even ordering. By the time I got my food, I was expecting a bit more.
0
Reply
NicholasPlescia
March 17, 2026
"I was at Pickle Barrel last week, the..."
I was at Pickle Barrel last week, the main thing I noticed was how clean everything was. I’m the kind of person who pays attention to the tables, washrooms, and little messy corners more than anything else, and I didn’t really have anything to complain about. The tables weren’t sticky, the washrooms were tidy, and even though it was busy, staff were quick to clear things up. That kind of stuff stands out to me, so I really appreciated it. 5 stars.
0
Reply
elisa_Moll90
March 15, 2026
"I’ve ordered from picklebarrel.ca a few times now..."
I’ve ordered from picklebarrel.ca a few times now, it’s been fresh every time. The veggies are crisp, the bread doesn’t taste stale, and even the salads taste fresh, not like they’ve been sitting around all day.
It’s just simple, good food, and I like that it shows up tasting pretty much the same as when you eat there. I’d definitely order again, for sure...
It’s just simple, good food, and I like that it shows up tasting pretty much the same as when you eat there. I’d definitely order again, for sure...
0
Reply
thomas1978
February 27, 2026
"Got seated way faster than I expected"
We went in on a busy night, and I was already bracing myself for a long wait because the place looked packed. I think I had even brought a phone charger in my jacket pocket just in case we were stuck hanging around forever. But we got seated surprisingly quick. The food came out faster than I expected too, which was nice because I was starving by then. The staff definitely looked like they had a lot going on, but they still stopped by to check on us. Overall, no complaints from me at all. The wait time was way better than I thought it would be
0
Reply
MichaelMurray_48
February 17, 2026
"Solid value and plenty to eat"
I wasn’t expecting huge portions, but from the way they talked it up, I figured it would be filling, and it definitely was. For the price, I got more than enough and still had leftovers for later.
0
Reply
Vern_wells73
February 09, 2026
"The staff were so nice and welcoming..."
The staff were so nice and welcoming. Like, they smiled when I walked in, answered my questions without making me feel rushed, checked in to make sure I was okay, and just had a really friendly attitude the whole time. Little things like that make a big difference.
0
Reply
hello_michael083
January 26, 2026
"Decent takeout, but I expected it to be quicker"
I ordered takeout from Pickle Barrel through their site, and the pickup process was easy. The staff were friendly enough, but my order ended up being about 15 minutes late, which was a bit frustrating because I was expecting a faster response and turnaround.
The food was still warm when I got it, but it didn’t feel quite as fresh by the time I got home. Portions were decent, though one of the sides was missing. Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience, just average for the price.
The food was still warm when I got it, but it didn’t feel quite as fresh by the time I got home. Portions were decent, though one of the sides was missing. Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience, just average for the price.
0
Reply
PatriciaHoltmeier_93
January 20, 2026
"Pretty much nailed the order"
I ordered dinner from picklebarrel.ca kind of on a whim, my first reaction was, okay nice, they got almost everything right. All the main stuff was there, and the portions looked exactly like what I picked online.
The only little hiccup was that one side was swapped out, but we weren’t too bothered by it. The sauces were included, and they actually followed the special notes, which immediately made me feel better about the whole thing.
Overall, it was a solid order and I’d definitely do it again. Just hoping next time that tiny mix-up doesn’t happen, but it didn’t ruin dinner or anything.
The only little hiccup was that one side was swapped out, but we weren’t too bothered by it. The sauces were included, and they actually followed the special notes, which immediately made me feel better about the whole thing.
Overall, it was a solid order and I’d definitely do it again. Just hoping next time that tiny mix-up doesn’t happen, but it didn’t ruin dinner or anything.
0
Reply
gabriela.Scott
January 19, 2026
"Decent food, but the prices made me pause"
I ordered from picklebarrel.ca it was alright. The food showed up warm, the portions were decent, and at first I was like, okay, this is a solid choice.
But then I looked at what I paid and suddenly my mood changed a bit. Like, wait a second, for that price I kind of expected more. I’d probably order again if there was a promo or deal, but at full price it feels just okay.
But then I looked at what I paid and suddenly my mood changed a bit. Like, wait a second, for that price I kind of expected more. I’d probably order again if there was a promo or deal, but at full price it feels just okay.
0
Reply
Epifania-herz
January 09, 2026
"I ordered from picklebarrel.ca and was actually really..."
I ordered from picklebarrel.ca and was actually really happy with it. The chicken was juicy, the sauces had a lot of flavor, and nothing tasted bland, which is always a win in my books. The portions were decent too — not one of those meals where you’re still hungry after, thankfully. I’d definitely order again when I’m in the mood for something simple, filling, and good.
0
Reply
John.dixon
December 30, 2025
"Decent vibe, but loud"
The place had a decent vibe overall, but it was definitely louder than I expected. It was kind of hard to relax or have a normal conversation, and that part was weird. Still, the atmosphere wasn’t bad...
0
Reply
rose_Glosson74
December 24, 2025
"I had to wait quite a bit before..."
I had to wait quite a bit before someone was able to help me, which was a little frustrating. It wasn’t like anything terrible happened, but when you’re standing there or sitting on hold and you’re not really sure how long it’s going to take, it starts to feel longer than it probably is. Once I finally got help, it was fine, but the wait was definitely slower than I expected...
0
Reply
hello_charles648
December 22, 2025
"Not the best dessert moment"
I was kind of excited for the cake, honestly. Looked nice enough. But then I took a bite and… yeah, dry. Not much flavor either. Just one of those desserts where you keep hoping the next bite is better, but it isn’t really. Wouldn’t say it was worth getting again
0
Reply
Have a question about The Pickle Barrel?
Log in to ask your The Pickle Barrel question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
